Casper vs Tempurpedic Mattress Review 2020

The top bed in a box meets the top bed in a showroom

The Casper vs Tempurpedic comparison is inevitable. Having two leading brands from different backgrounds get pitted against each other is necessary for customers to have a more nuanced understanding of the choices they’ve got.

Casper is the one often credited for starting the online mattress revolution. It took the old-fashioned memory foam, bumped up its breathability, compressed it, and then placed it in a box for convenient delivery. It’s been 5 years since, and the company has not looked back. Now Casper is poised to scale even more.

Tempurpedic is also considered innovative in the traditional mattress industry. It arrived in the United States through the Swiss in 1992. The cushioning technology it introduced was based on the research made by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA). And it has become a trusted brand across the country and all over the world since.

Our guide will delve into the similarities and differences between the two leading brands. We hope to shed light on what makes them unique and competitive. As many mattress models appear here and there, they continue to stand out. Why is that?

Casper vs Tempurpedic Mattress Comparison

Preview
Best Price
Casper Sleep Foam Mattress, Queen 12"
Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt 11-Inch Medium Hybrid Foam...
Comfort Level
Firm
Firm
Material Type
Foam
Hybrid
Mattress Height
10"
10"
Price
$995.00
$2,199.00
Customer Rating
Best Price
Preview
Casper Sleep Foam Mattress, Queen 12"
Comfort Level
Firm
Material Type
Foam
Mattress Height
10"
Price
$995.00
Customer Rating
Preview
Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt 11-Inch Medium Hybrid Foam...
Comfort Level
Firm
Material Type
Hybrid
Mattress Height
10"
Price
$2,199.00
Customer Rating

Casper vs Tempurpedic Mattress Review

Both Casper and Tempurpedic have several mattress models under their name. We are not going to compare and contrast all possible combinations. First, that doesn’t seem the right way to start.

At the least, we can have the all-foams go against the all-foams, the hybrids go against the other hybrids. Second, there is a more efficient way to introduce the companies to you: through their flagship models.

That said, we would like to present the Casper Original Mattress and Tempur-Adapt.

Construction & Materials

The two options we just mentioned are all-foam mattresses. This makes it easy to see how they fare in terms of the factors to consider before you buy a mattress. And foremost, you have to know what’s inside the thing you’re lying in or on.

Inside the Casper Original Mattress are four layers of foam with different functionalities. The zoning features highlight this construction. Read on to find out more:

  • Comfort Layer – This model is topped by a thin, airy polyfoam layer. This guarantees that as you drift off to dreamland, you are comfortable and cool.
  • Memory Foam Layer – Inside the Casper, memory foam functions to provide contouring relief. Your pressure points are targeted and cradled in a customized way.
  • Transition Layer – The ZonedSupport is a proprietary tech from Casper that enhances the middle layer’s conformity. To align your spine naturally, it allows your shoulders to sink a little more than your hips.
  • Support Layer – A 5-inch, high-density polyfoam enhances support while providing durability to the bed.
  • Polyester Cover – A softcover in a white-and-gray combo completes the construction.

On the other end, the signature material of Tempurpedic was taken from NASA’s studies into cushioning aircraft seat fabrics. It’s an element added to save airborne individuals during an emergency. That cushioning tech can be discovered in the Tempur foam. 

Tempurpedic is primarily a memory foam mattress brand. This bed type consists of a comfort layer of memory foam and a core support layer of high-density polyfoam. Nearly all of its designs have these basic building blocks. The Tempur-Adapt only has these two.

The thing about traditional companies like Tempurpedic is that they can get away without telling us more specific details about their materials. You can think about those as trade secrets. Online mattress brands like Casper, however, thrive by being transparent about their materials.

Winner: Casper

Casper Sleep Foam Mattress, Queen 12"
  • Casper’s award-winning bed-in-a-box mattress offers 12" and 4 layers of premium foam, plus zoned support for comfort and alignment
  • Designed for all body types, our Zoned Support system features three areas of support, for optimal spinal alignment, no matter your height or weight
  • Breathable open-cell foams have tiny pores to let hot air escape, keeping you cool at night

Firmness & Feel

Legend

1 is soft, 10 is firm

  • Ultra Soft – 1-2
  • Soft – 3-4
  • Medium – 5-6
  • Firm – 7-8
  • Ultra Firm – 9-10

The Firmness Scale shown above is a guideline for many mattress manufacturers. It is common among bed-in-a-box companies. It works for some. But for others, they are either compelled to modify their beds’ firmness scores based on customer feedback or develop fresh models that deliver the right feels.

A medium firmness offers the “not too soft, not too firm” feel that many sleepers need. It is called the universal comfort. Both Casper and Tempurpedic strive to nail this, even if they also dish out other models and firmness options to cater to the wider market.

Critics and customers alike give Casper a medium firmness score. This bed caters to sleepers of any preferred position and of any size. So if you sleep on your back, side, or stomach, this one’s for you. Since this model is specialized in zoned assistance, the third layer adjusts to your pressure points by being firmer at the hips, firm at the shoulders, and less firm at the knees.

Casper vs Tempurpedic

With gentle support to the legs, the spine is aided in going into its natural alignment. With Casper, your posture is being corrected while you snooze. Those on the heavier side may have to look for something else, though.

Tempur-Adapt also has a medium firmness score (5 on the scale). Side and back sleepers can benefit the most from it. The following weight groups are also accommodated by Tempur-Adapt. 

  • Lightweight – 90 pounds and below
  • Average weight – 90 to 130 pounds
  • Heavyweight – 130 pounds and above

Winner: Casper

Read our full review of the different Casper mattress models.

Cooling

All-foam designs are infamous for trapping heat, particularly those with memory foam. Yet, innovative ones that use this material know that allowing air to circulate within the foam layers improves breathability. So they are now making memory foams with an open-cell structure for this purpose. Another recognized alternative is the phase change technology. And then there are those that infuse it with gel, copper, graphite, and other elements.

With Casper, you get to maximize this open-cell technology. Its layers have small pores that allow air to escape rather than be trapped. This promotes breathability across the bed. But some consumers report that it tends to sleep hot as the night deepens. It may be the way the layers adhere to each other. It may be the high-density polyfoam that hampers ventilation all the way to the bottom.

Of course, Tempurpedic is mainly an all-foam mattress brand. It is pretty familiar with the classic memory foam problem. The Tempur-Adapt actually includes a memory foam with excellent contouring. Its so-called traditional memory foam is now infused with cooling components as well. The foam is also designed so the air that flows through the layers stays fresh.

Tempur-Adapt is one of the models in the Adapt line. This line is known for featuring cooling elements in the comfort layer. A cooling cover is added to boost breathability. Does it work? Yes. But some users say it can sleep warm.

Winner: Tie

Edge Support & Sinkage

What is edge support? And how important is it? It depends on your case. If you sleep with someone else and tend to sleep toward the edge, this is important. Edge support is the strength enforced at the perimeter, which allows for stable support for sleepers who use this site a lot. It can also prevent premature sinkage.

However, all-foam mattress types are typically poor performers in this area. The addition of springs can definitely improve this, which is why the hybrid versions of Casper and Tempurpedic offer great edge support. 

But the original Casper provides only fair edge support. This means you will feel unstable when you roll toward its edge. Some describe this as feeling like they’re falling off the floor. Aside from this situation, it also makes your bed more prone to early sagging. This can occur more quickly if you like sitting on the edge in the day on top of lying on it at night.

Tempur-Adapt is slightly better in this regard because of its high-density core layer. It offers some stability when you take your perimeter spot to snooze. It can also lengthen your bed’s life span a little. But there is no guarantee the surface won’t become uneven over time if you overuse the edge.

For couples, siblings, pet parents, or small families, you can instead take advantage of a hybrid model with superior edge support.

Winner: Tempurpedic

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt 11-Inch Medium Hybrid Foam...
  • 11-INCH MATTRESS: Medium-feel hybrid foam mattress.
  • LAYERS OF FOAM: TEMPUR Support Layer and TEMPUR-ES Comfort Layer offer advanced adaptability for truly personalized comfort and support.
  • HYBRID-TECHNOLOGY: Mattress includes over 1000 premium spring coils designed to work with TEMPUR material and delivers ultimate support.

Motion Transfer

What is motion transfer? This refers to the transfer of movement from one area of the mattress to another. This can feel like a shock or a shake, depending on the person generating the movement. It can also be very subjective. But if you are a light sleeper who can have a hard time staying or falling asleep after being awakened, it helps to pay attention to this factor.

Getting an uninterrupted slumber may be virtually impossible if your situation is as we described. Your sleep health can be negatively affected. So it’s a must to find a mattress that can insulate motion well. The desired result should be little to no motion transfer. Memory foam beds are good at this. So, do Casper and Tempurpedic deliver?

It turns out Casper has a remarkable performance in this regard. It can contain movements in one part of the bed and transfer only a small percentage of them to the other part. For sure, there is still a lot of room for improvement. But the original mattress is off to a good start. This is good news for those who are sharing their sleeping surface with someone who’s fidgety. 

Now, Tempur-Adapt eliminates movement transfer altogether in many instances. Maybe it’s the memory foam paired with high-density polyfoam, but this bed lets you sleep without distractions even if your partner is a combo sleeper. In this department, the long-time memory foam mattress specialist wins.

Winner: Tempurpedic

Pricing

Online mattress companies have offered alternatives that are cheaper than traditional mattress prices. They’ve cut down the cost of employing a middleman and operating physical stores. This way, they can pass down the savings to you. From the opposite perspective, you have giant retailers giving you upward of $1,000 options. You can bank on their brand integrity and time-tested performance. If you can afford it, won’t you take it?

Let’s look at the more affordable one first. Casper is in a position to balance affordability with high quality. The queen version of the original retails at $995. It has a hybrid version that doesn’t exceed $1,500. The price points are within the market average, and so more customers are reached by Casper. If someone wants a luxurious touch, they can apply for financing and buy a Casper.

The Tempur-Adapt costs $2,199. This is one of the company’s least expensive mattresses. The price for this memory foam bed is still high, as this is the most affordable type out there. But you know you are paying for the assurance that you’ll get only the most excellent sleep here. For those who have been dreaming of owning a Tempurpedic bed, you can start with the Tempur-Adapt.

In this case, we believe that Casper is the one you should go for if your budget is within the mid-range. And Tempurpedic should be your choice if you have at least $2,000 to splurge on a mattress. To each his or her own.

Winner: Tie

Other Factors

Like the one that made compressed beds in boxes popular, the Casper will naturally deliver your Casper Original Mattress without additional charge. It comes with customer-centric perks, such as a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty

The three months you can spend to test out the mattress is fair enough. If you realize within that duration that it isn’t the right fit, you may request a return. Casper will shoulder the pickup and shipping costs for you. 

Now, Tempurpedic has an advantage as an established mattress provider. Its policies are more nuanced, although some of them come with a price. For instance, you can have your Tempur-Adapt delivered to you for free via standard shipping. But you may ask for a next-day air delivery or a second-day air delivery. You will be charged for $40 per order or $25 per order, respectively. All deliveries are via UPS.

If you live within the continental US, Tempurpedic offers you free white glove delivery and mattress removal. If you are ordering from Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, and other US territories, you will have to pay $25 per order. 

You can test out your Tempur-Adapt for 90 nights. In case of a return, you are required to break in the bed for 30 nights. Only after then will the company process your return request. Don’t worry because it will refund you in full. If you want to keep it, you get access to a 10-year non-prorated warranty. Sounds good?

Winner: Tempurpedic

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt 11-Inch Medium Hybrid Foam...
  • 11-INCH MATTRESS: Medium-feel hybrid foam mattress.
  • LAYERS OF FOAM: TEMPUR Support Layer and TEMPUR-ES Comfort Layer offer advanced adaptability for truly personalized comfort and support.
  • HYBRID-TECHNOLOGY: Mattress includes over 1000 premium spring coils designed to work with TEMPUR material and delivers ultimate support.

Pros & Cons

Casper Mattress

Pros
  • Has zoning features for effective pressure relief.
  • Medium firmness caters to many sleepers.
  • The more affordable option.
Cons
  • Has weak edge support.
  • Some users report that it sleeps warm.

Tempurpedic Mattress

Pros
  • Contains cushioning tech based on NASA’s research.
  • Contouring comfort is superior for this model.
  • Eliminates motion transfer.
  • Customer-centric policies have great terms.
Cons
  • The more expensive option.
  • Not transparent about its materials.

Conclusion

Tempurpedic wins this Casper vs Tempurpedic comparison! It is a small lead, considering how Casper scores points on some important factors. Yet, as our guide shows, Tempur-Adapt is still the reigning memory foam mattress online and offline. You get premium-grade materials, excellent customer service, and a trusted source for your sleep needs. It’s worthy of the investment you are about to make.

At the same time, Casper is more than just an alternative. It’s the best bed in a box to have as it is reliable, durable, and affordable. While it is in the mid-range, many types of the budget can buy it. You can say it’s the people’s mattress. And nobody really lost here. 

Of course, the ultimate winner should be you–the customer. You have to know which one is the right fit for you. The budget is just one part of the equation. And now, you have the information you need to make a smart decision. Should you go for Casper or Tempurpedic?

Keep in mind the things we’ve shared here. Use them to decide which brand and model suit your style. You can also browse other articles on phatfusion.net to explore your options. If you have special needs, you may check out our Ghostbed vs Purple mattress review

And drop us a message in the comments if you have questions or suggestions. ‘Til later!
Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: