Best Wool Mattress Toppers in 2020 Reviews

Do you want to enhance the elevation or feel of your existing mattress? For those who are looking for a more practical and less expensive alternative to replacing their mattress, shopping for a topper may be the best option. 

When it comes to mattress toppers or mattress pads, why don’t you choose a material that can be used all year round, regulate temperature, allow the sleeping surface to breathe, and protect you from allergy triggers? It won’t hurt if it’s also naturally soft.

We’re talking about no less than the wool mattress topper. Unlike synthetic fibers that score low on breathability, the fibers of natural wool let air flow freely throughout mattresses and beddings. At the same time, they have excellent temperature neutrality. Wool is also one of the most durable topper components on the market.

If you’re allergic to latex or unsatisfied with cotton, why not try wool instead? To help you decide, here are our top picks of the best wool mattress toppers, as well as the pros and cons of using wool.

Best Wool Mattress Toppers in 2020

1. PlushBeds Natural Luxury Handmade Wool Topper

This model sets itself apart with a 3-inch thick design. The PlushBeds Natural Luxury Handmade Wool Topper is one of the thickest toppers around, catering to individuals on the heavier side. It balances sink and support with its all-natural wool composition. 

The material is naturally breathable and resistant to dust mites and mold spores. It’s also excellent in regulating temperature, making for a year-round sleep accessory. 

For the peace of mind of eco-conscious shoppers, its components are locally and sustainably sourced. These include the cotton sateen cover with a 400 thread count for that soft and smooth finish. With all these luxurious touches, this bedding does not come cheap. It’s one of the higher-end options out there, with huge discounts during holiday sales.

Read: What is the Best Time to Buy a Mattress?

Why We Like It

• Uses sustainably sourced wool
• Supportive and breathable
• Can prevent asthma and allergies

2. Sleep & Beyond myMerino Topper

A close second is the Sleep & Beyond myMerino Topper. Its main material is organic merino wool, which is superior to other types of wool. Merino fibers are superfine, allowing the topper to breathe and the air to circulate. Together with the cotton cover, this component is certified organic.

This model belongs to the thinner side with a 1.5-inch profile. Lightweight to average-weight users can benefit from its soft surface. It’s suitable for all sleeping positions, especially if you prefer a plush top layer for your pressure points.

The myMerino Topper is less expensive than the PlushBeds wool topper, but it is still pricey. It comes with a 5-year warranty. You can also return it for exchange or refund within 45 days of the date of purchase.

Why We Like It

• Made of superior merino wool
• Supportive and breathable
• Ideal for lightweight to average-weight users

3. OrganicTextiles Wool Mattress Topper 

If you find the first two choices limiting in terms of weight capacity and sleeper type accommodation, the OrganicTextiles Wool Mattress Topper probably won’t disappoint you. Made with organic Australian wool, this mattress pad can bring comfort and support to users of all shapes and sizes.

Side, stomach, back, and combination sleepers can enjoy the temperature neutrality it offers all year. It includes straps to prevent it from sliding around or off the mattress. It’s stable, no matter how frequently you shift in bed at night. Lightweight to heavyweight individuals may appreciate these features, too. At one-inch thick, it may feel too thin for some users.

This hypoallergenic topper is wrapped in a 100% cotton cover. It will cost you around $200 to own this product.

Why We Like It

• Made with Australian wool
• Caters to all sleeper types
• Accommodates any weight

4. SnugFleece SnugSoft Elite Wool Mattress Topper

Are you searching for the ultimately plush mattress pad? The SnugFleece Elite Wool Mattress Topper is your best bet in this department. With a unique design, this bedding lets you snooze directly on the wool. So it can make you feel like you’re floating on a cloud. Don’t worry if you have sensitive skin as the pure wool material is hypoallergenic.

Supporting the exposed wool layer is a layer of cotton backing. Overall, the topper is 1.5-inch thick. But you’ll probably hardly notice how thin it is due to superior softness this sleep accessory provides. It’s fuzzy enough to keep you warm during colder months. But it’s not too thick to trap heat during hotter times.

This product comes with straps to keep it in place. Young children to senior adults can enjoy lying down on this one. It is machine-washable, so it’s easy to clean and maintain. It’s well within the average market price, but some may consider it a bit pricey.

Why We Like It

• Allows sleepers to lie directly on wool
• Provides a super plush option
• Can adjust to body temperature

5. Perfect Fit | Cool Wool Reversible Mattress Pad

Taking it up a notch is the Perfect Fit | Cool Wool Reversible Mattress Pad. It features two sides that can be used based on your preference. You can have pure Australian wool if you prefer that side and plain-weave cotton if you reverse the topper. These materials yield the same softness, but you can adjust the feel of your sleeping space for better customization.

Sandwiched between these sides is a layer of a down-alternative fill. It is made of polyester fiber, which gives the mattress pad its resilience and loft. Those who sleep cool can flip it to the cotton side. Snooze on the wool if you need to keep warm on chilly winter or autumn nights.

This 2-inch-thick topper is firm with a touch of softness, which can help relieve joint pains. It’s machine-washable as well. If you want a cheaper alternative to the SnugFleece offering, this one’s for you.

Why We Like It

• Has dual, reversible sides
• Works any time of the year
• Highly affordable

6. Parachute Wool Mattress Topper

Conformity from a wool mattress topper: is that possible? The Parachute Wool Mattress Topper serves up virgin wool that cradles your pressure points. It is also resilient, so it doesn’t retain body impressions. It’s also not prone to the effects of compression. This makes for a longer-lasting surface.

The temperature-regulating feature of wool is found in this model as well. During winter, it will warm you up. When it becomes hotter, it will dissipate heat away from your body. It will work well with people who experience night sweats. But it will provide cooling comfort to anyone in general.

You’ll probably like that this wool is antimicrobial. The manufacturer recommends to dry-clean it. You don’t have to wash it regularly, but airing it out may help keep it clean and fresh. This item falls on the higher end of the price range. So it’s perfect if you have a bigger budget.

Why We Like It

• Cradles you pressure points
• Does not leave body impressions
• Temperature-regulating

7. Century Home Signature Collection Woolmark Mattress Topper

The name is quite a mouthful, but the Century Home Signature Woolmark Mattress Topper is not all talk. Its 100% pure Australian wool brings you the breathable, temperature-regulating goodness only this material offers. In whatever season, your body will adjust its temperature with the aid of this topper.

You can sleep directly on the wool, but that may feel a bit strange. Unfortunately, the product does not come with a cover. But you can always use a mattress protector to cover both the pad and the mattress. The backing is also thin, so it might not be ideal for individuals who snooze on their backs. And the wool may not be of the highest quality you can find. 

This model comes in four different sizes. You can machine-wash and dry it as you please, but line-drying may cause it to last longer. You only need to shell out around $80 to take this bedding home.

Why We Like It

• Uses 100% pure Australian wool
• Has excellent temperature regulation
• One of the most affordable models

8. Sleep Philosophy WonderWool Mattress Pad

Inside this product is the 10% wool and 90% polyester padding called WonderWool. It combines both materials to balance comfort, loft, and durability. Even with the smaller portion of wool, this mattress pad exhibits all the qualities you love about wool. Breathability and temperature regulation top the list. The 100% cotton casing completes the construction of this model.

This resilient topper works with mattresses that are up to 15 inches deep. It’s hypoallergenic, so it can protect you from dust mites, mold, mildew, and pet dander, among others. Despite the cooling effects of wool, polyester may prevent air from circulating freely. So this is not recommended for those who sleep hot.

This mattress pad is cushy, a perfect choice for people who sleep on their side. It can fit any standard-size bed snugly, except for California King. This product retails at under $100. 

Why We Like It

• Ideal for side sleepers
• Fits 15-inch-deep beds snugly
• Costs under $100

Factors to Consider Before Buying a Wool Mattress Topper

Temperature

The human body needs to cool down in preparation for sleep. If the fibers of a topper are not breathable, you may feel the heat build-up as you snooze. This can prevent you from falling asleep or interrupt your sleep. This is also why the trend of cooling mattresses has emerged. If your sleeping space sleeps hot, you may not be maximizing the time spent lying on it.

Good thing wool is naturally breathable. And it can regulate temperature to suit your needs. So if you need cooling down, its fibers will wick heat and moisture away from your body. If you need warming up, it can insulate heat to make you feel warm and cozy.

Firmness

A wool topper can fix wear-and-tear problems. It’s an excellent addition to an aging mattress that you are not quite ready to replace. If the issue can be resolved without sacrificing your comfort and sleep quality, then place a wool mattress pad on your sleeping surface. It can help even out the spots where sagging, lumps, or popped springs have appeared.

Further, this material is chosen more for its pillowy softness. So if you end up with a mattress that’s too firm, you can use a wool topper to adjust the firmness. It’s particularly useful to side sleepers who need plush support for their hips and shoulders. Some wool mattress pad models may also have firmer versions, with some sink-in feel, for stomach and back sleepers. 

Composition

Wool is one of the materials that can be sustainably sourced. Its fibers are derived from the coat of sheep, goats, and alpacas. The resulting products are preferred for their fluffiness. The soft material brings comfort that can aid individuals in achieving better sleep. 

As we said earlier, those who need warmth during winter can also benefit from its insulating properties. During hotter days, wool can keep the surface cool because of its thermoregulating capabilities.

Sensitivities

Do some materials trigger your allergies or asthma? It could be latex or feathers. If you want a topper that’s naturally hypoallergenic, try one that’s made of wool. It should be resistant to dust mites and other potential allergens. So it’s suitable for people who have sensitive skin and are prone to allergies.

Co-Sleeping

Customizing firmness on either side of the bed is possible with wool toppers. You can place one layer on one end for the partner who prefers a soft surface. Add two or more on the other for the partner who wants a firmer feel.

If you’re sharing your bed with another person, you might also appreciate how silent wool is. However, it does not reduce motion transfer significantly.

Pricing

Wool is an expensive material used in mattresses and bedding. On average, wool mattress pads cost $150 to $300. But organic versions can go as high as $500,  so it’s probably not the best choice for individuals on a budget. All of these figures are for queen-size models.

In comparison, a memory foam topper is priced between $100 and $250. Latex ones start at $100 but can also reach $400. The cheapest options may be polyfoam and polyester fiber.

Care and Cleaning of Wool Mattress Toppers

Is machine-washing and drying wool mattress pads a no-no? Not anymore. You can toss your topper into the washer, preferably a front-loading one, and wash in cold water on a delicate cycle. To dry, you can use the tumble dry or air cycle setting. However, most wool topper owners choose line-drying or dry-cleaning their bedding.

If your topper has a zipped cover, you can remove the cover and wash it instead. Place the inner part in a clean and dry place while you clean the outer part. For items with instructions not to machine-wash or dry clean, spot-clean them with soap and water. Usually, these are organic or untreated natural wool.

To be sure, always check the label before performing any care and cleaning activities.

Benefits of Using Wool Mattress Toppers

Heat Retention

Wool can hit two birds with one stone. During warmer months, it can wick moisture and let air circulate to cool down hot sleepers. During colder months, it can insulate heat to keep you warm.

Softness

Is your sleeping surface too hard? If you can’t return it or replace it yet, adding a mattress topper may resolve the issue. Wool is soft enough to add a thin layer of cushioning without affecting the elevation and temperature of your bed.

Read: 8 Tips On How To Make A Mattress Softer

Hypoallergenic

Wool has hypoallergenic properties, so it is perfect for people with allergies and sensitive skin. 

Noiseless

If you frequently shift at night or sleep lightly, you can trust that the wool topper won’t make scratchy noises to betray or disturb you.

Downsides of Buying Wool Mattress Toppers

Motion Transfer

If you’re co-sleeping, you will probably appreciate minimal to no motion transfer. Wool is not good at it, though. It can transfer movements generated from the other side of the mattress.

Minimal Conformity

Wool does not conform closely to your body. If you have issues with your pressure points—neck, shoulders, lower backs, and hips—a wool mattress pad may provide little relief.

Odor

Wool emits a smell that may not sit well with some people. The odor doesn’t go away with years.

High Price

Toppers made of wool tend to be on the expensive side. So if you are on a budget, this option is not for you.

Conclusion

Do the benefits of using wool outweigh the downsides? Do you think you’ll be fine with the care and maintenance of a wool mattress topper? Which among our top picks are you eyeing?

Pardon our many questions. We just want to keep your mind active after reading our reviews and tips. We shared these not to overwhelm you but to inform you about the things you must know before buying a wool topper. After all, this purchase is on the expensive end. And you want to make the most out of your money.

Our top pick is the PlushBeds Natural Luxury Handmade Wool Topper. It perfects the wool mattress pad trifecta: breathable/temperature regulating, comfortably soft, and made by hand using high-quality materials. It’s more straightforward than other designs, but it packs a lot of value-adding features.

If this option does not suit your needs and preferences, we have seven more models for you to consider. May you choose wisely.